There’s little left to say about Public Enemies that Brett McCracken (who is working on a book on hipster Christianity that is sure to be a must-read) hasn’t already said.  

More than anything, Public Enemies revels in and inflates Dillinger’s mythic status.  Depp’s portrayal is sympathetic to the last.  Dillinger refuses to kill the innocent bystanders or take their money.  He is in it for the money and for the noteriety, not for the slaughter.

As Brett points out, Depp’s Dillinger is always in control of his own self-image.  Even his flirtation with unsteadiness of mind, an unsettling performance of ‘Git Along Little Dogie’ after escaping, is carefully crafted by Dillinger to make everyone else in the car think that he wasn’t quite right in the head.  No jail can hold him, no bank can keep him out, and no girl can stand him up.  He, if anyone, is Nietsche’s ubermensch, controlling the world and its understanding of him by the exertion of his will.  

It is for this reason that we remain emotionally detached from Dillinger.  Despite the movie’s attempts to draw us into his world through his friendships and romance, by the end we are ambivalent toward him.  Such is the inevitable result of a mediated world, a world saturated with images and celebrities.  We watch Dillinger watch Clark Gable on the big screen (a blatant parallel, down even to the mustache).  Dillinger, the star of his own movie, is just as reserved from us as Gable.

Dillinger’s romance with Billie Frechette comes close to remedying this detachment, but fails.  We know as much about her as we do about Dillinger.  She too cares nothing for tomorrow, as evidenced by her monumental failure of discernment. 

Public Enemies is a well crafted film, to be sure.  It’s plodding, brooding narrative and stunning cinematography are enjoyable in their own right.  But it is most interesting for what it lacks–a strong sense of connection between the audience and characters.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Posted by Matthew Lee Anderson

Matthew Lee Anderson is the Founder and Lead Writer of Mere Orthodoxy. He is the author of Earthen Vessels: Why Our Bodies Matter to our Faith and The End of Our Exploring: A Book about Questioning and the Confidence of Faith. Follow him on Twitter or on Facebook.

One Comment

  1. This has been one of the most enlightening/embarrassing experiences for me worshiping in majority-AA church… that there are worlds of nonwhite Christian thought that I haven’t even heard about.


Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published.