Then read Bainbridge’s response here. He politely says what everyone is thinking.
Then check out Dr. Reynolds riff on Sullivan’s second post here. The money quote:
Sullivan: His theology is indeed distinguished, if somewhat esoteric and at times a little odd.
Reynolds: Any bets on how many Ratzinger books Sullivan has actually read?
I’m going to aim high and guess two.
Perhaps RomanCatholicBlog says it best:
Then again, how else would Sullivan react? Short of Benedict XVI had come out on the balcony and declared, “Everything I said before about homosexuality? Fuggedaboutit! Gays can get married!”, nothing would have made Sullivan happy.
To quote The Blogger, “Heh.”