Remember Terri Schiavo?

Like Schiavo, Jesse Ramirez, a gulf war veteran who was comatose as a result of a car accident, was slated to have his feeding tubes removed.  They were taken out for five days but then replaced when the Alliance Defense Fund, a pro-life organization in Arizona, sued.

On Tuesday, he “was found to have regained complete consciousness.”

This remarkable turnaround reminds us that perhaps the chief virtue of the ethical decision maker is modesty, a virtue that has more applications than clothing.  Because doctors in these situations are deciding between life and death, it seems there ought be a prima facie position in favor of keeping the patient alive.  Such a position is more modest and more restrained, it seems, than the alternative, as it acknowledges the limitations of our knowledge not only of the future, but of human personhood.
These sort of ethical dilemmas are only increasing, which increases the need for such modesty.  Science is advancing into new ethical terrain all the time.  Consider the chimeras, fusions of humans and animals that William Saletan wrote about recently.  Or the technologizing of humanity, which is so helpfully described in this BBC documentary.  In both areas, science is operating without guidelines that are clear and well defined. Because of the high stakes, it seems a judicious restraint is essential, at least until such guidelines can be established.

Of course, we do not live in a culture that values modesty.  Whether it is clothing, religion, or technology, we lack the caution that is befitting our limited perspectives and positions.

What does modesty look like in bioethics?  I’m not sure, but the weight of such decisions demands a restraint greater than the medical and scientific communities seem to be demonstrating.  After all, more lives like Jesse Ramirez’s hang in the balance.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Posted by Matthew Lee Anderson

Matthew Lee Anderson is the Founder and Lead Writer of Mere Orthodoxy. He is the author of Earthen Vessels: Why Our Bodies Matter to our Faith and The End of Our Exploring: A Book about Questioning and the Confidence of Faith. Follow him on Twitter or on Facebook.

One Comment

  1. […] A few months ago, I claimed that modesty is an essential virtue for bioethicists, but was unsure what shape such modesty might take: What does modesty look like in bioethics?  I’m not sure, but the weight of such decisions demands a restraint greater than the medical and scientific communities seem to be demonstrating. […]

    Reply

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *