Outside of a few pieces on the underlying philosophical issues at stake in the health care debate, I have stayed relatively quiet about my position on it.

But with a landmark vote coming in the House of Representatives this weekend, I want to second what Al Mohler had to say about it:

I have refrained from extended comment on the health care reform bills — not because I do not have multiple concerns about the bills, but because I recognize that committed Christians can and will disagree over the political and policy issues involved. The trip-wire for me is the issue of human life. The current bill spells disaster when it comes to abortion. I cannot remain silent in this crucial moment where the sanctity of human life is at stake.

For those readers who are in favor of the bill, I hope you’ll continue to read and argue with me.   That’s why I write.  But having read the language of the Senate bill, it’s pretty clear to me that it provides federal funding for abortions, and it’s precisely that language which would get enacted into law if the House passes their reconciliation package.

As Bart Stupak, who has become the leading voice for the pro-life community on this issue, points out, the Democratic insistence on passing the bill without additional pro-life protections is grounded in motivations that are deeply troubling:

What are Democratic leaders saying? “If you pass the Stupak amendment, more children will be born, and therefore it will cost us millions more. That’s one of the arguments I’ve been hearing,” Stupak says. “Money is their hang-up. Is this how we now value life in America? If money is the issue — come on, we can find room in the budget. This is life we’re talking about.”

In short, there’s a lot at stake on this bill, and there’s good reason to oppose it.  Health care for all is a good, and we do need to pursue it.  But any action that attempts to do so that simultaneously provides funding for abortion violates the Pauline principle, doing harm that good may come.

There are few times I’ve encouraged direct political action through Mere-O.  That’s not really our thing.

But in this case, with this much at stake, I would encourage you to contact your representatives by phone, email, or fax and let them know precisely where you stand on this issue.  AUL Action is a great place to start.  And I have no doubt Hugh Hewitt will be updating his list of people who are still on the fence.  And you can tell the pro-life Dems, as I have, to Stand with Stupak.

I’ll probably be following the proceedings some on Twitter, too, where you can follow me for more updates on this issue.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Posted by Matthew Lee Anderson

Matthew Lee Anderson is the Founder and Lead Writer of Mere Orthodoxy. He is the author of Earthen Vessels: Why Our Bodies Matter to our Faith and The End of Our Exploring: A Book about Questioning and the Confidence of Faith. Follow him on Twitter or on Facebook.


  1. So what I’m hearing is “health” is more important than “life”. hmmmm…


  2. Matt: Now here is an issue which I think fully deserves to fly under a ‘mere orthodoxy’ banner for every sensible Christian. Anyone who claims to be a disciple of Christ and fails to understand that the right to be born is fundamental to any just society is either ignorant, which may be forgivable, or incapable of sound judgment, or is obstinately blind. Every other right stands upon this one unequivically.

    Posterity will hold our society in deeper contempt than the societies which produced American Slavery or the Holocaust of Hitler. The systematic slaughter of 50 million persons makes the Slaughter of the Innocents appear humane.

    The apathy of a materially affluent society has never been more evident than it is in ours. American Christianity’s embrace of this world indicates their insipid and obtuse perception. As Richard Weaver said, “we have become a nation of moral idiots”.

    If this sounds harsh consider, as Belloc said, that “we are watched by large and awful faces from beyond, and on these faces there are no smiles.”

    Christ have mercy.



Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published.