my review of Jamil Jivani’s “Why Young Men?”

June 11th, 2018 | 2 min read

I reviewed Jamil Jivani’s new book, Why Young Men?, for Comment magazine. It’s a fascinating (and sometimes frustrating) book that explores the very important question of why young men are radicalized and embrace violence. It is a bit tricky to nail down his central thesis, but his main themes center around the idea that young men experience alienation as a result of racism, nonfunctional state institutions (mostly the police and schools), and lack of job opportunities. This alienation is amplified by fatherlessness and family dysfunction.

true true

Want to keep reading?

Subscribe for free to access this article and all of our resources.

Matthew Loftus

Matthew grew up in a family of 15 children and completed his medical training in Baltimore, Maryland. Since 2015, he and his family have lived in East Africa, where he currently teaches and practices Family Medicine at a mission hospital. His work has appeared in outlets such as The New York Times, The Atlantic, The New Atlantis, and Mere Orthodoxy and his first book is forthcoming from InterVarsity Press. You can learn more about his work and writing at www.matthewandmaggie.org and preorder his forthcoming book here: https://www.ivpress.com/resisting-therapy-culture

Topics:

Family

Culture

Economics

Criminal Justice

Education

my review of Jamil Jivani’s “Why Young Men?”

Want to keep reading?

Keeping Kids Christian: Bonus Q and A

Leaving Home to Save It

In Relation to God: A World Down Syndrome Day Reflection

How Marriage Actually Refers to Christ and the Church

Discipleship Begins in the Home (But the Church Is Essential Too)

Marriage, Family, and the Intellectual Life: Interview with John and Katelyn Shelton

The Goodness of Caring for Other People's Children

Marriage, Family, and the Intellectual Life: Charles and Tessa Carman

The Need for Father-Scholars

In This House of Death: What Does Sanctity of Human Life Month Mean in 2026?

Why It Is Difficult to Talk About Ethics of the Body

Freebirth in an Age of Hospitals

Shaping Conscience on Issues where Scripture is Silent

Misunderstanding Porn

Discernment, Angst, and Vocational Celibacy

Sex, Virtue, Technology

On Contraception, Tradition, and the Wise(r) Use of Christian History

Parenting an Autistic Child in 2025

The Separation of Woman and Womb: A Warning

Sexuality and the Need for Moral Guidance

Desiderata for a Protestant Theology of the Body

The Case Against Vasectomies

Cats and Sixty Foot Whales: Reflections on Children’s Books

Markets and the Strangulation of the American Family

Tethered Still